Is All Airway Protection Acute Respiratory Failure?

Original story posted on: July 16, 2018

Document it right on the front end; avoid fighting a denial on the back end

I was recently asked about a post from Hospital Performance regarding acute respiratory failure and airway protection (, and I wanted to expand on what the author, Dr. Hesham Hassaballa, wrote. A key point is where he says, “the fact that the patient is not awake enough to maintain an open airway to promote gas exchange implies to (him) the presence of acute respiratory failure.” This subject is particularly relevant to clinical validation denial, as respiratory failure is a prime target for auditors.

His ideal documentation was modeled as “acute respiratory failure secondary to inability to maintain an open airway due to encephalopathy.” I think this patient is less “unable to maintain an open airway” and more “not breathing frequently enough to sustain life.”

The way I think about “airway protection” is that the patient’s airway literally needs protecting. It is endangered by blood, secretions, vomitus, inflamed tissue, or a foreign body. If you insert a tube from the outside to the inside to open up the upper airways and the patient doesn’t need supplemental oxygen or increased ventilation, then that is airway protection. You must also exclude from the respiratory failure calculation patients upon whom ventilation is iatrogenically imposed, because they must be sedated and paralyzed to endure being intubated for their “airway protection.” Bona fide airway protection is a rare occurrence.

The issue could be upper airway, pulmonary, cardiovascular, musculoskeletal, neurological, or hematological, but the ultimate consequence of respiratory failure is characterized as inadequate gas exchange by the respiratory system – which, left unchecked, will result in incompatibility with life.

The question I tell my students to ask themselves is this: “Can this patient’s respiratory system oxygenate and/or ventilate without my assistance (other than providing a conduit for room air to pass)?” A nasal trumpet or an endotracheal tube, for example, giving safe passage to ambient gas exchange without intervention by bagging or electricity (CPAP, BiPAP, ventilator) is solely airway protection. If additional assistance is necessary to support oxygenation or ventilation, consider it respiratory failure.

In order to determine whether there is acute hypoxic or hypercapnic respiratory failure, you need to allow the oxygen level to drop or the carbon dioxide to rise. If the patient is not breathing sufficiently (i.e., hypoventilating), such as in an overdose or due to a brain bleed, my opinion is that it would be malpractice to wait for them to develop the blood gas derangement just to justify the formal diagnosis. I never endorse altering medical practice for coding purposes.

No one is more supportive of ICD-10 specificity than me, but this is a situation where I would declare “acute respiratory failure” and let type be left undetermined. The purpose of respiration is to exchange gases. Oxygenation is bringing oxygen in from the inspired air, and ventilation is offloading carbon dioxide that has been generated during cellular respiration (glucose + O2 = CO2 + H2O + energy). If a patient is hypoventilating, he or she is destined to become both hypoxic and hypercapnic without intervention.

I would amend Dr. Hassaballa’s suggested verbiage to read: “acute respiratory failure due to central hypoventilation from encephalopathy.” If a patient truly requires airway protection, I would document “intubation for airway protection due to facial trauma” and would not use a code for any type of respiratory failure. Just keep in mind, if the patient needs non-iatrogenically-mandated oxygenation or ventilation (i.e., you didn’t paralyze them and cause the requirement for oxygen or ventilation), in other words anything other than a cleared passage for free air movement, you are dealing with some type of respiratory failure.

Document it right on the front end so you don’t have to fight a denial on the back end.

Comment on this article

Disclaimer: Every reasonable effort was made to ensure the accuracy of this information at the time it was published. However, due to the nature of industry changes over time we cannot guarantee its validity after the year it was published.
Erica E. Remer, MD, CCDS

Erica Remer, MD, CCDS has a unique perspective as a practicing emergency physician for 25 years, with extensive coding, CDI, and ICD-10 expertise. She was a physician advisor of a large multi-hospital system for four years before transitioning to independent consulting in July 2016. Her passion is educating CDI specialists, coders, and healthcare providers with engaging, case-based presentations on documentation, CDI, and denials management topics. She has written numerous articles and serves as the co-host of Talk Ten Tuesdays, a weekly national podcast. Dr. Remer is a member of the ICD10monitor editorial board, a former member of the ACDIS Advisory Board, and the board of directors of the American College of Physician Advisors.

Related Stories

  • Understanding the Nuances of Coding Malnutrition
    March is National Nutrition Month. In honor of National Nutrition Month (March), here is a review of weight-related diagnoses. The Official Coding and Reporting Guidelines for ICD-10-CM state that other clinicians may document body mass index (BMI), but the provider…
  • Proposed Biannual ICD-10 Implementation Dates: Weighing the Pros & Cons 
    Understanding the impact on business processes in the event that biannual ICD-10-CM and PCS updates are implemented is essential – as is your feedback.  With a comprehensive agenda covered at the virtual ICD-10 Coordination and Maintenance Committee meeting earlier this…
  • Arriving Soon: Code U09.9, Post-COVID-19 Condition
    The new code is expected to be here in October. EDITOR’S NOTE: The following is the broadcast script from Dr. Erica Remer’s segment during Talk Ten Tuesdays, March 16, 2021. One of the highlights of my year, and most definitely in…