Making the Connection: DNA, NCD, and CMS

Original story posted on: February 18, 2019

  • Product Headline: ICD10monitor Educational Webcasts Subscription
  • Product Image: Product Image

A National Coverage Determination (NCD) will reimburse providers for diagnostic tests using sequencing.

Today’s topic is DNA sequencing and its effect on society as a whole, on healthcare, and on Medicare. Sequencing is a laboratory procedure that maps the pattern of nucleotides in DNA.

In 2003, sequencing an individual cost $2.7 billion; by 2006, it was $300,000; and now, the entire genome can be sequenced for $700, with some tests running around $50.

There are four nucleases – cytosine, guanine, adenine, and thymine – abbreviated C-G-A-T. A sugar called deoxyribose with a phosphate group link them into a chain. Hydrogen bonds tie together two chains with base pairs of A/T and C/G.

These DNA strands are long. In only one of the 46 human chromosomes, there are around 220 million base pairs. These chains are torn apart, and the newly created sequence of nucleases helps build proteins. But the system fails some of the time. Most of the time, a failure really doesn’t matter, but sometimes it does, and in a big way. Such as with cancer. By taking the DNA of normal humans and comparing it to the DNA of humans with a special disease, it is possible to determine where the problem is.

A Genome-Wide Association Study

The BRCA gene linked to breast cancer was found this way. A single protein glitch can cause incredible problems. If your DNA at the 9p21.2 location gets messed up, then a single protein is not made, and you can get Lou Gehrig’s disease.

DNA profiling also allows for genetic fingerprinting. It is used in criminal investigations, in finding out who the father really is, or in identification of persons when there is not much left to go on, such as after an airplane crash.

Personalized medicine, or pharmacogenomics, uses genetic information to help identify optimal therapies for individual patients. It also makes it possible to find out if you may be susceptible to certain diseases.

Type 2 diabetes risk can be identified through sequencing. This gives an opportunity to change lifestyle before it is too late. Today’s current rage is the use of DNA sequencing to discover one’s ancestry. People sometimes are surprised to learn that their ancestors are from some very unexpected places. If everyone in the United States took a DNA test, they would quickly realize how mixed up everyone is, and racism would (hopefully) disappear.

In Medicare, DNA sequencing is being used for patients with advanced cancer. The current administration has finalized a National Coverage Determination (NCD) that will reimburse providers for diagnostic tests using sequencing. For example, the F1CDx test is a companion diagnostic for 15 targeted therapies. It looks for genetic mutations in 324 genes and two genomic signatures in any solid tumor.

We should all be proud that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) is covering the most advanced DNA sequencing techniques, and at the same time driving research to even greater heights.

Comment on this article

Edward M. Roche, PhD, JD

Edward M. Roche is the founder of Barraclough NY LLC, a litigation support firm that helps healthcare providers fight against statistical extrapolations. Prior to joining the California Bar, Dr. Roche served as the chief research officer of the Research Board (Gartner Group) and chief scientist of the Concours Group, both leading IT consulting and research organizations.

Latest from Edward M. Roche, PhD, JD

Related Stories

  • How PDPM Could Make Catching Bad Guys More Difficult
    Under PDPM, reimbursement will be driven by coding and documentation. South Florida has historically been a hotbed of healthcare fraud, and there is a long list of those responsible other than Philip Esformes, who was sentenced to 20 years in…
  • Graduate Medical Education Payments: Do we Need to Fix the System?
    With the reimbursement so complex and antiquated, should Congress investigate? Medicare reimbursement payments to hospitals for graduate medical education are based on calculations so complicated, it boggles the mind.  The computation for direct graduate medical education (GME) payments starts with…
  • Hospice Payments Proposed at $540 Million for FY 2020
    The Medicare Hospice Benefit proposed rule includes payment rates, wage index, and cap amount.  The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) is proposing to increase hospice payments to $540 million in the 2020 fiscal year, an increase of 2.7…